Shell Structures

Introduction

Shell structures are thin, curved surfaces that efficiently carry loads primarily through in-plane (membrane) stresses. Because form and force align, shells can span long distances with minimal material, producing striking architecture—domes, barrel vaults, saddle-shaped (hyperbolic paraboloid) roofs, tanks, and silos. This guide explains what shells are, how they work, the main types and materials, analysis and design steps, and construction considerations. We connect each concept to a continuous load path, realistic loads, rigorous analysis, and sound foundations.

Great shells are “form-active”: choose a geometry that naturally carries the load in tension or compression with minimal bending.

What Are Shell Structures & Why Use Them?

A shell is a surface with one or two curvatures whose thickness is small relative to its span. Unlike prismatic beams or plates, shells achieve efficiency by aligning curvature with load flow, so forces run in the surface rather than bending through the thickness. When well-detailed, shells provide superb span-to-weight performance, excellent stiffness, and expressive forms.

  • Advantages: Long spans with minimal thickness, architectural freedom, rapid enclosure, and integral diaphragm action.
  • Tradeoffs: Geometry sensitivity, buckling risks, careful edge detailing, specialized analysis, and tighter construction tolerances.
  • Best fits: Arenas, terminals, tanks, reservoirs, iconic roofs, lightweight canopies, silos, and thin concrete shells for acoustic/thermal mass benefits.

Use Cases

RC domes for tanks and arenas, hypar canopies for plazas, steel grid shells for atriums, FRP sandwich shells for lightweight roofs, and timber gridshells for pavilions.

Shell Types & Materials

Shells vary by curvature and structural action. Materials include reinforced concrete (RC), steel, aluminum, FRP/composites, and timber gridshells. Select based on span, exposure, fabrication, and desired aesthetics.

  • Single-Curvature: Cylindrical/barrel vaults; carry loads along the curved direction but need stiffening in the generator direction (ribs, edge beams).
  • Double-Curvature (Positive): Domes (synclastic curvature); membrane compression predominates under symmetric gravity loads.
  • Double-Curvature (Negative): Saddles/hypars (anticlastic curvature); tension and compression fields cross; good wind uplift performance when detailed.
  • Folded Plates: Faceted plates emulate curved shells; straightforward forming; efficient diaphragms.
  • Grid Shells: Lattice (steel/timber) that follows a curved geometry; cladding provides enclosure; efficient and visually light.

Did you know?

Many “iconic” shells are actually hypars—they’re straight-line generable, enabling economical formwork: ideal where budget meets ambitious geometry.

Mechanics: Membrane vs. Bending

Shell behavior blends membrane forces (in-plane) and bending (out-of-plane). Well-chosen forms carry most loads in membrane action; bending rises near edges, openings, supports, and under asymmetric loads (wind, seismic).

Membrane Forces (Concept)

\( \{N_\phi,\,N_\theta,\,N_{\phi\theta}\} \rightarrow \text{in-plane resultants per unit length} \)
\(N\)Membrane force (tension +, compression −)
\(M\)Bending moment per unit length
\(\kappa\)Curvature; geometry drives force flow

Geometry Matters

\( K = \kappa_1 \kappa_2 \quad \Rightarrow \quad K > 0 \text{ (domes)},\; K < 0 \text{ (saddles)} \)
\(\kappa_1,\kappa_2\)Principal curvatures
  • Load paths: Gravity in domes ⇒ hoop compression + meridional forces; saddles ⇒ crossing tension/compression bands.
  • Edge effects: Edges “attract” bending—use edge beams/rings to tame stress concentrations.
  • Imperfections: Small geometric or load imperfections can trigger bending/buckling—account for them in design.

Analysis & Design Workflow

Shell design combines form finding, linear/nonlinear analysis, local detailing, and constructability planning. Start with idealized membrane behavior, then add bending, stability, and serviceability checks.

Step-by-Step

Define loads & combinations from code (dead, live, wind, seismic, thermal) → choose geometry that favors membrane action → size thickness & reinforcement (RC) or member sizes (grid shells) → perform FE shell analysis (include imperfections for buckling) → detail edges, rings, ribs, and openings → verify deflection, cracking, vibration, and durability → coordinate with formwork, segments, or panelization → finalize anchors to foundations.

Strength (Concept)

\( \phi\,N_n \ge N_u \;,\; \phi\,M_n \ge M_u \quad \Rightarrow \quad N_n = f_y t \text{ (steel)} \; \text{or} \; N_n \sim 0.85 f’_c t \text{ (RC compression)} \)
  • RC shells: Reinforcement follows principal stress directions; additional bars/ribs near edges and openings; crack control limits bar spacing.
  • Grid shells: Member buckling and joint stiffness govern; check global and local stability under service and ultimate loads.
  • Connections: Capacity design—ensure ductile elements yield before brittle failures at anchors or edges.

Stability, Buckling & Edge Conditions

Thin shells are sensitive to buckling from compression bands, geometric imperfections, and edge conditions. Robust boundaries (ring beams, edge stiffeners) stabilize the form and control deformations.

Buckling (Concept)

\( \lambda = \dfrac{\sigma_{cr}}{\sigma_{applied}} \quad\Rightarrow\quad \text{use knockdown factors for imperfections} \)
  • Ring Beams: Domes need a tension/compression ring to resolve hoop forces; detail splices and anchorage carefully.
  • Ribs & Folds: Stiffen long generator lines in vaults; reduce panel spans and control vibrations.
  • Supports: Continuous vs. discrete supports change stress patterns; provide bearings that allow thermal movement.

Coordination Tip

Edge beams often control architectural depth. Align gutters, skylight frames, and façade joins with structural rings to hide stiffness where it’s needed most.

Openings, Penetrations & Details

Skylights, ducts, and access openings disrupt membrane flow, creating local bending and stress concentrations. Frame or thicken locally, redirect forces with ring stiffeners, and provide water management at penetrations.

  • Reinforcement: Ring bars around openings in RC; frames/gussets in gridshells; avoid sharp corners—use rounded or elliptical edges.
  • Waterproofing: Drape waterproofing to follow curvature; integrate gutters at edge beams; ensure redundancy at joints.
  • Thermal Movement: Provide slip details for cladding and skylights; continuous air/water barriers compatible with curvature.

Important

Do not cut openings in shells after construction without engineering review. Even small penetrations can trigger global redistribution and local buckling risks.

Construction, Formwork & QA/QC

The success of shell projects hinges on buildability. Choose methods that achieve the geometry precisely and maintain tolerances.

  1. Formwork & Casting (RC): Segmental or reusable forms; control lifts, vibration paths, and curing to avoid differential shrinkage.
  2. Prefabrication: Panelized RC (thin precast), steel or timber gridshell kits; coordinate splice/joint details and crane reach.
  3. Tolerances: Survey geometry at key stages; small deviations can change stress paths.
  4. QA/QC: Concrete strength, cover, and crack width checks; bolt/weld inspections for gridshells; membrane continuity for waterproofing.
  5. Closeout: As-builts including survey points and reinforcement photos support long-term inspections.

Wind, Seismic & Dynamics

Curved forms experience complex wind pressures and suctions; seismic loads introduce membrane-bending interaction. Early coordination with wind design and seismic design prevents late-stage surprises.

  • Wind: Check localized suction at ridges/edges; ensure cladding/anchors resist fluctuating pressures.
  • Seismic: Provide ductile edges and collectors to transmit inertial forces; check support uplift and sliding.
  • Dynamics: Low mass shells can be lively—verify natural frequencies and damping; see structural dynamics.

Vibration (Concept)

\( f_n \sim \dfrac{1}{2\pi}\sqrt{\dfrac{k_\text{global}}{m}} \;\Rightarrow\; \text{stiffer edges, ribs, or thicker zones raise } f_n \)

Inspection, Monitoring & Repair

Over time, shells can show cracking (RC), joint relaxation (gridshells), or corrosion at edge details. A monitoring plan preserves performance.

  • Routine checks: Crack maps, moisture intrusion at openings/edges, and anchor corrosion.
  • NDE: Cover meters, GPR for RC; bolt tension checks and weld NDT for steel/timber gridshells.
  • Repairs: Resin injection for fine cracks, external FRP/steel ribs, replacement of corroded anchors, and waterproofing renewal.

Lifecycle Snapshot

Maintain sealants/gaskets, clean gutters, inspect skylight frames, and verify edge ring continuity after heavy storms or seismic events.

Codes, Standards & Trusted References

Use authoritative, stable resources for design and research on thin shells and spatial structures:

  • International Association for Shell and Spatial Structures (IASS): Research and best practices. Visit iass-structures.org.
  • NIST: Structural performance and resilience resources. Visit nist.gov.
  • ACI: Concrete shell design and detailing resources. Visit concrete.org.
  • ASCE: Load standards and structural guidance. Visit asce.org.
  • NASA Technical Reports: Classic thin shell buckling research. Visit ntrs.nasa.gov.

For related topics, see structural loads, confirm your analysis approach, coordinate wind design and seismic design, and finalize foundation design and inspections.

Frequently Asked Questions

When should I choose a dome vs. a saddle (hypar)?

Domes excel under symmetric gravity loads and create compression-dominant membrane fields; hypars handle asymmetric loads and wind well with crossing tension/compression bands. Architectural openness, drainage, and support layout often decide.

How thin can an RC shell be?

Often L/200 to L/300 governs thickness, but cover, durability, and constructability set a practical minimum (e.g., 60–100 mm). Local thickening at edges/openings is common.

Are shells expensive?

Formwork and precision can raise unit costs, but material savings and rapid enclosure offset expenses. Hypars and folded plates use repetitive forms to control budgets.

Do shells need expansion joints?

Yes, long shells benefit from thermal joints aligned with geometry and waterproofing strategy. Supports should accommodate thermal movement without inducing restraint cracking.

Can I retrofit an existing shell?

Yes—add edge ribs/rings, external FRP/steel stiffeners, or internal frames. Verify geometry, material properties, and existing reinforcement before intervention.

Key Takeaways & Next Steps

Shell structures deliver unmatched material efficiency and expressive space when geometry, mechanics, detailing, and construction are aligned. Favor membrane action with smart forms, control edge effects with rings and stiffeners, and respect construction tolerances. Analyze with realistic imperfections and load patterns, then maintain performance with targeted inspections and waterproofing.

Continue with our guides on structural analysis, check structural dynamics, validate wind design and seismic design, and deliver reactions to robust foundations. For standards and research, rely on IASS, ASCE, ACI, NIST, and NASA NTRS. Thoughtful geometry + disciplined detailing + precise construction = shell structures that perform for decades.

Scroll to Top